Talking Point: Should Linux Distros Stick to CDR Size?
It’s starting to look like the end of an era for Ubuntu users as Canonical mull the creation of an ISO that won’t fit onto a CDR. The question is, does it matter?
Ubuntu should be pushing network installers, if they really want to keep things under 700MB use LXDE (Lubuntu) for the CD version.
Updates after an install makes internet connections necessary anyway. Creating a rolling release installer to keep things up to date would be far move valuable. Besides, if the computer can handle Unity and has an optical drive chances are it’s a DVD/CD player anyway.
Optical Media is dead, move up to a 1GB Flash Drive threshold if necessary.
My off topic opinion on Ubuntu: I hate all the branding based on desktop environment, I think it’s pointless and Canonical is the only one that sees value in splitting projects under different names. As a new user a few years back it confused the hell out of me.
For me a perfect CD installer starts minimal with LXDE, Openbox, or XFCE. GNOME and KDE would be an upgrade option.
I think this really depends on the distro as well as the user. I’ve uninstalled more than probably comes on most CDR-based installation discs, so I personally enjoy the netinstall option (especially since I prefer rolling release distros). The netinstall option seems to be the best for those that are already experienced.
I feel like distros with a similar goal as Ubuntu (i.e. usable for a wide range of users) probably need to have more options (although not so many as to be confusing). I rather like the way Linux Mint handles this (see here). You can get the DVD version with all the fancy things; or you can get just the basic CD version.
Side note: I agree that “Ubuntu” needs to just refer to all the Ubuntus. It really doesn’t make sense to call them different names. Especially since you can install all the different “flavors” from any of them, anyway. Just have more options for install discs or some sort of option on installation. If I install “Kubuntu”, but then install GNOME, neither “Ubuntu” nor “Kubuntu” seems appropriate, anymore. Especially, if we are basing names off of graphical interface, what if I install some other random DE/WM? DWMbuntu?
(larger version here: